SCHEDULE OF ORAL ARGUMENTS
September Term, 2025
Monday, May 4, 2026:
Bar Admissions
AG No. 5 Attorney Grievance Commission of Maryland v. Sara Mohamed Samy El-Shall
No. 55 Clennie Murphy, III, et al. v. Government Employees Insurance Company
Issues – Insurance Law – 1) Should Costello v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, 143 Md.App. 403 (2002) be overruled because the case applies an insurance policy’s household exclusion to non-household wrongful death beneficiaries? 2) Is Costello applicable to this case since the GEICO policy at issue does not define “derivative claims” or “wrongful death”?
No. 56 Prince George's County, Maryland v. Joseph Watts
Justice Getty will sit in place of Justice Killough.
Issues – Torts – 1) Did ACM err in finding that employment discrimination and retaliation claims are not torts? 2) Did ACM err in finding that the General Assembly did not intend for the Local Government Tort Claims Act (“LGTCA”) apply to statutory claims? 3) Did ACM err in not finding that the LGCTA statutory damages cap applies to Watts’ “Other Damages” award, which are damages indistinguishable from traditional tort damages?
Tuesday, May 5, 2026:
No. 57 Montay D. Shuler v. State of Maryland
Issues – Criminal Law – 1) Does a defendant lose his right to an otherwise apt jury instruction on the voluntariness of his pretrial statement simply because it was offered for impeachment purposes or because the content of his statement is “exonerating”? 2) Is the “some evidence” standard for requesting a jury instruction on voluntariness indeed a “low threshold” under the totality of the circumstances in which the statement was made or must a defendant generate specific evidence of improper inducement, threats, or coercion?
No. 58 The Council of Unit Owners of the Millrace Condominium, Inc., et al. v. Shapiro Sher Guinot & Sandler, P.A., et al.
Issue – Torts - Malicious Use of Process – Can the victims of an action determined to be a bad faith SLAPP (Strategic lawsuit against public participation) suit pursuant to Courts & Judicial Proceedings § 5-807 maintain a cause of action for damages under the malicious use of process doctrine?
After May 5, 2026, the Court will recess until June 4, 2026.
On the day of argument, counsel must register in the Clerk’s Office no later than 8:30 a.m. unless otherwise notified.
GREGORY HILTON
CLERK