Court of Special Appeals Archive of Oral Arguments

In response to the COVID-19 Emergency, and in line with Administrative Orders issued March 17, 2020 and later, oral arguments in the Court of Special Appeals beginning in April 2020 have been conducted on remote videoconferencing platforms. Recordings of those arguments are archived here. In addition, remote oral arguments in June 2020 are being streamed live on the Court’s webpage.

Due to limitations of the videoconferencing platforms, archived videos do not show all of the participants in the oral arguments and prioritize the current speaker. Furthermore, because of the limitations of the videoconferencing platforms, limitations of participants’ internet bandwidth, and other factors, there are video and sound distortions in some of the recordings of the arguments.

July 2020 Schedule

Date
Docket Number
Title
July 15, 2020
No. 2372, September Term, 2019
In re: J.T. and G.N.
July 7, 2020
No. 2405, September Term, 2019
Adepoju Olarinde v. Kehinde Korede
July 7, 2020
No. 2544, September Term, 2019
In re: S.R.-F.
July 6, 2020
No. 3472, September Term, 2018
Dennis Hamilton v. Murray Rottenberg, et al.
July 2, 2020
No. 22, September Term, 2019
Reneice J. Ramsay v. John E. Driscoll, III, et al.
July 2, 2020
No. 1231, September Term, 2019
Evelyn Neal v. Tersita Rogers
July 2, 2020
No. 3470, September Term, 2018
1501 Southern LLC v. John E. Driscoll, III, et al.
July 2, 2020
No. 1879, September Term, 2019
William O. Loeffler v. Lisa Loeffler
July 2, 2020
No. 1, September Term, 2020
State of Maryland v. Tyron Green
July 2, 2020
No. 3350, September Term, 2018
Rony Galicia v. State of Maryland
July 2, 2020
No. 731, September Term, 2019
Tarrone Barfield v. State of Maryland

June 2020 Schedule

Date
Docket Number
Title
June 30, 2020
No. 778, September Term, 2019 (Audio Only)
John Durniak v. Michele Bourdelais
June 17, 2020
No. 734, September Term, 2019
Sharon Giles Simmons v. Hyundai Motor America
June 17, 2020
No. 814, September Term, 2019
Paul Asmussen v. CSX Transportation, Inc
June 17, 2020
No. 3162, September Term, 2018
Grady Management, Inc. v. Rediet Birru
June 17, 2020
No. 3322, September Term, 2018
Saxons, Inc. v. Mackenzie Retail, LLC
June 17, 2020
No. 48, September Term, 2019
Joseph G. Rayman, III v. Wayne D. Rayman
June 17 2020
No. 822, September Term, 2019
Aeisha Haynes v. Disability Review Board
June 17, 2020
No. 1419, September Term, 2019
Edward Felton v. State of Maryland
June 17, 2020
No. 1503, September Term, 2019
Edward Effion Hill v. State of Maryland
June 16, 2020
No. 88, September Term, 2019
Brian C. Givens et al. v. Euro Motorcars Colission Center, Inc
June 16, 2020
No. 776 & 1726, September Term, 2019
Heidi Rosencrantz Ryder v. Charles Ryder
June 16, 2020
No. 887, September Term, 2019
Varsity Investment Group, LLC v. Prince George’s County
June 16, 2020
No. 2971, September Term, 2018
Nelson Elick v. Keefe Commissary Network, LLC
June 15, 2020
No. 541, September Term, 2019
Sherrie Lynn Smith v. Marshall T. Horman
June 15, 2020
No. 646, September Term, 2019
Jamaal Taylor v. Tokio Marine Ins. Co
June 15, 2020
No. 801, September Term, 2019
Tysean A. Lipford v. State of Maryland
June 15, 2020
No. 939, September Term, 2019
Jeanne Marie Johnson et al. v. Lindsay Golden, et al
June 15, 2020
No. 3454, September Term, 2018
Alexi Ortiz v. Alfred D. Walsh, Jr
June 15, 2020
No. 109, September Term, 2019
Kenneth J. Dias, Jr. v. The Estate of Waltraut I. Ciccone
June 15, 2020
No. 648, September Term, 2019
Katherine Packett v. Univ. of Maryland Medical Center
June 15, 2020
No. 1066, September Term, 2019
Ronnie Barnes, Jr., et al. v. Univ. of Md. Medical Sys. Corp
June 15, 2020
No. 2069, September Term, 2019
In re: J.T.
June 5, 2020
No. 283, September Term, 2019
Brutus 630, LLC v. Harford County, Maryland et al.
June 5, 2020
No. 699, September Term, 2019
Nina Bolling v. Bay County Consumer Finance, Inc.
June 5, 2020
No. 834, September Term, 2019
The Cincinnati Insurance Co., et al. v. Elisabeth S. Shuster
June 5, 2020
No. 3385, September Term, 2018
Mahiri Jones v. Affordable Home Improvements, LLC
June 4, 2020
No. 590, September Term, 2019
Mark Eppard et al. v. RDC Harbourtowne, LLC, et al.
June 4, 2020
No. 764, September Term, 2019
Baltimore City Police Dept. v. Andre Robinson
June 4, 2020
No. 781, September Term, 2019
Estate of Anthony A. Hammond, Jr., et al. v. Michael Cox, et al.
June 4, 2020
No. 1858, September Term, 2019
In Re: L.W.
June 4, 2020
No. 2649, September Term, 2018
In Re: L.W.
June 4, 2020
No. 588, September Term, 2019
Walter Burch Noel, III, et al. v. TD Auto Finance, LLC
June 4, 2020
No. 805, September Term, 2019
Brytani Sumby v. Linda Jackson
June 4, 2020
No. 3408, September Term, 2018
Frank Bucolo v. Diana Bucolo Van Dyke
June 4, 2020
No. 3492, September Term, 2018
Joseph Weber v. Fire and Police Employees’ Ret. Sys.
June 3, 2020
No. 2766, September Term, 2018
Clifford Butler v. State of Maryland
June 3, 2020
No. 3523, September Term, 2018
Michael Collett v. State of Maryland
June 3, 2020
No. 579, September Term, 2019
West Montgomery County Citizen’s Assoc. v. Mont. County Planning Board
June 3, 2020
No. 1365, September Term, 2019
Edward Andre Bodeau v. State of Maryland
June 2, 2020
No. 1253, September Term, 2019
In re: S.B.
June 2, 2020
No. 760, September Term, 2019
Isabel Galvez Lopez v. Steven Martinez
June 2, 2020
No. 817, September Term, 2019
Jacquetta N. Dixon v. Criminal Injuries Compensation Board
June 2, 2020
No. 998, September Term, 2019
Brandon Harrington Ware v. State of Maryland
June 2, 2020
No. 2103 & 2104, September Term, 2019
Tanya Majied v. Robert Anderson
June 2, 2020
No. 1228, September Term, 2019
Joshua Whaley v. State of Maryland
June 1, 2020
No. 754, September Term, 2019
Karl Daniel Geiger v. Backstage LLC, et al.
June 1, 2020
No. 1556, September Term, 2019
Jennifer McAnany v. Erik S. McKenzie
June 1, 2020
No. 2890, September Term, 2018
Ashton Lee Frisby v. State of Maryland
June 1, 2020
No. 665, September Term, 2019
William Burris, et al. v. Ted Bauer, et al.
June 1, 2020
No. 3289, September Term, 2018
Dwayne Scott Lockard v. State of Maryland
June 1, 2020
No. 413, September Term, 2019
Giant of Maryland LLC v. Karen Webb

May 2020 Schedule

Date
Docket Number
Title
May 12, 2020
No. 979, 980, 982, 983, 985, 988, 989, 991, 992, 993, 994, September Term, 2019
Baltimore Police Department v. Brooks, Durant, Fried, Histon, Jones, Jordan, McBride, Rivera, Whittaker, Worsley, Sowers, and others
May 12, 2020
No. 1683, September Term, 2019
Alexander Bathula v. Anna L Travis, et al
May 12, 2020
No. 27, September Term, 2019
Clark Office Building, LLC. v. MCM Capital Partners, LLLP., et al
May 12, 2020
No. 501, September Term, 2019
Maria Henriquez-Carbajal v. State of Maryland
May 12, 2020
No. 581, September Term, 2019
MB Maple Lawn LLC, et al v. Consumer Protection Division
May 12, 2020
No. 341, September Term, 2019
Helen Mrose v. Samuel Boles
May 11, 2020
No. 1440, September Term, 2019
Candice Brooks v. Norman Brooks
May 11, 2020
No. 320, September Term, 2019
Alexander Bathula v. Anna L Travis, et al
May 11, 2020
No. 544, September Term, 2019
Clark Office Building, LLC. v. MCM Capital Partners, LLLP., et al
May 11, 2020
No. 2807, September Term, 2018
Comptroller of Maryland v. Broadway Services Inc.
May 8, 2020
No. 849, September Term, 2019
Allan Myers, L.P. v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore
May 8, 2020
No. 1046, September Term, 2019
Maryland Department of Health v. Jamal Lateef Sheffield
May 8, 2020
No. 1012, September Term, 2019
Michael Geoffrey Jamsa v. State of Maryland
May 8, 2020
No. 351, September Term, 2019
Martin Moise Chery v. State of Maryland
May 8, 2020
No. 436, September Term, 2019
Malcolm Jordan v. State of Maryland
May 8, 2020
No. 545, September Term, 2019
Serguei Timachev v. Marina Lobas
May 7, 2020
No. 2666, September Term, 2018
Stuart Fink v. Morris H. Fink Trust, et al.
May 7, 2020
No. 318, September Term, 2019
Octavia T. Coit, et al. v. Nicole Nappi, et al.
May 7, 2020
No. 1134, September Term, 2019
Luke Daniel Johnson v. State of Maryland
May 7, 2020
No. 400, September Term, 2019
Melissa Mills v. Peter Mills
May 6, 2020
No. 733, September Term, 2019
D'Angelo Wright v. State of Maryland
May 6, 2020
No. 1088, September Term, 2019
Reginald Allen v. State of Maryland
May 6, 2020
No. 1886, September Term, 2019
In re: D. J., H. J., and P. J.
May 6, 2020
No. 770, September Term, 2019
Raheen Edwin v. State of Maryland
May 5, 2020
No. 104, September Term, 2019
Shabazz Watkins v. State of Maryland
May 5, 2020
No. 510, September Term, 2019
Russell Kurt Jacobs, Jr. v. State of Maryland
May 5, 2020
No. 517, September Term, 2019
United Behavioral Health v. EX REL J.D.S. o.b.o. C.N.M.
May 5, 2020
No. 614, September Term, 2019
Prince George's County Volunteer Fire and Rescue Association, et al v. Prince George's County, Maryland
May 5, 2020
No. 730, September Term, 2019
Wilson Homes, Inc. et al. v. Chris E. Putnam, et al.
May 4, 2020
No. 998, September Term, 2018
Ronald Richardson v. Maryland Department of Health and Mental Hygiene
May 4, 2020
No. 568, September Term, 2019
Junior Johnson v. State of Maryland
May 4, 2020
No. 599, September Term, 2019
Montie Lamont Hayman v. State of Maryland
May 4, 2020
No. 883, September Term, 2019
GenOn Mid-Atlantic, LLC v. Maryland Department of the Environment, et al
May 4, 2020
No. 884, September Term, 2019
GenOn MidAtlantic, LLC. v. Maryland Department of the Environment, et al
May 4, 2020
No. 885, September Term, 2019
NRG Chalk Point, LLC. v. Maryland Department of the Environment
May 4, 2020
No. 950, September Term, 2019
Deandre Malik Jacob v. State of Maryland
May 4, 2020
No. 3461, September Term, 2018
Corey Cunningham, et al. v. Baltimore County, Maryland et al
May 4, 2020
No. 532, September Term, 2019
Mary T. Newsom v. Brock & Scott, PLLC, et al
May 4, 2020
No. 1817, September Term, 2019
Shelton Alexander v. Tamara Alexander
May 1, 2020
No. 645, September Term, 2019
Jonathan Fogg v. Mustafa Eraibi, et al
May 1, 2020
No. 854, September Term, 2019
Kelvin Sewell v. State of Maryland
May 1, 2020
No. 1239, September Term, 2019
Nyshiem Inmon v. Jovan J Roberts, et al
May 1, 2020
No. 1242, September Term, 2019
Nyshiem Inmon v. Gregory Donnell Young, et al
May 1, 2020
No. 1585, September Term, 2019
John Hopkins Bayview Medical Center Inc. v. Erica Byrom, et al
May 1, 2020
No. 89, September Term, 2019
Brandi Hooker et al. v JN Property Solutions, LLC
May 1, 2020
No. 304, September Term, 2019
Dawn Carey v. Salisbury University
May 1, 2020
No. 484, September Term, 2019
University System of Maryland Salisbury University v. Sandra A Ramses
May 1, 2020
No. 485, September Term, 2019
University System of Maryland v. Karen Penuel

April 2020 Schedule

Date
Docket Number
Title
April 14, 2020
No. 561, September Term, 2019
James Mitchell v. State of Maryland
April 14, 2020
No. 147, September Term, 2019
Tara Treger v. Caleb Wade
April 13, 2020
No. 2318, Sept. Term, 2018
Estate of Norman J. Carter v. R&M Enterprises, Inc., et al.
April 13, 2020
No. 3334, September Term, 2018
Christopher Roberson et al. v. Board of Liquor License Comm’rs.
April 9, 2020
No. 789, Sept. Term, 2019
Maryland Office of People’s Counsel v. Maryland Public Service Comm’n (audio only)
April 8, 2020
No. 3392, Sept. Term, 2019
Kevin Butterworth v. Prince George’s County Police Dept.
April 8, 2020
No. 649, Sept. Term, 2019
Keith Merryman and FOP Lodge 146 v. Univ. of Baltimore
April 8, 2020
No. 858, September Term, 2019
Richard W. Williams v. State of Maryland
April 8, 2020
No. 3160, September Term, 2018
Jonathan Torin Kidder v. State of Maryland
April 7, 2020
No. 408, Sept. Term, 2019
Jerry Lee Jenkins v. State of Maryland
April 7, 2020
No. 2120, Sept. Term, 2018
Lisa K. Lane v. John C. Lane, Jr.
April 7, 2020
No. 528, September Term, 2019
Bryione Moore et al. v. Peak Management, LLC
April 7, 2020
No. 334, September Term, 2019
Larry S. Chavis, et al. v. Blibaum & Associates, P.A.
April 7, 2020
No. 147, Sept. Term, 2019
Alexander Langley v. State of Maryland
April 7, 2020
No. 8, Sept. Term, 2019
Sachinder Gupta v. Maryland Environmental Service
April 7, 2020
No. 2711, Sept. Term, 2018 and No. 832, Sept. Term, 2019
Peggy Ann Martin v. Jean Robert Dolet
April 7, 2020
No. 488, Sept. Term, 2019
Larry S. Chavis et al. v. Bilbaum & Associates, P.A.
April 7, 2020
No. 189, Sept. Term, 2019
Otagwyn Kambon v. State of Maryland
April 6, 2020
No. 2956, Sept. Term, 2019
Ernest Maxey v. Lockheed Martin Corporation
April 6, 2020
No. 171, Sept. Term, 2019
Circle 21 Cattle Company, LLC v. Laurence D. Casler
April 6, 2020
No. 866, Sept. Term, 2018
Joseph Skillman v. Paulen Industrial Center, Inc.
April 6, 2020
No. 659, Sept. Term, 2019
Coates v. Ford Motor Company
April 6, 2020
No. 215, Sept. Term, 2019
Dwayne Dease v. Addie Dease
April 6, 2020
No. 486, Sept. Term, 2019
Damien Gary Clark v. State of Maryland
April 6, 2020
No. 546, Sept. Term, 2019
Chanel Horton v. City Homes, Inc.
April 6, 2020
No. 1284, Sept. Term, 2019
Lauren Burleigh v. James Burleigh
April 3, 2020
No. 380, Sept. Term, 2019
In the Matter of Mary Joyce